Dossier: Ethics Outside the Human
Ethics Outside the Human: A Brief Introduction
Jordan Lev Greenwald
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
“When I look at it just from a
purely ethical standpoint . . . I think this is a frightening world.” So states
interdisciplinary artist and writer Coco Fusco in a Q&A regarding the
preparation of her 2013 performance piece Observations of Predation in Humans:
A Lecture by Dr. Zira, Animal Psychologist. It is a passing comment (Fusco is
responding to an audience question on the pervasiveness of neoliberal forms of
logic, calculation, and governance in everyday life) and yet one that speaks
directly to the nature of the performance in question and the attitude toward
the world it engenders. In Observations of Predation in Humans, Fusco takes on
the persona of the chimpanzee animal psychologist Dr. Zira, a pivotal character
in the Planet of the Apes films of the late 1960s and early 1970s. Dr. Zira, so
the backstory is presented to the audience (in a “Skype call” from none other than
Donna Haraway), did not actually die as she appears to in Escape from the
Planet of the Apes (1971), but rather feigned her death and has remained in
hiding since then, observing human behavior through television and film. In
the performance, Dr. Zira, an expert in primatology, neuroscience, and
evolutionary biology, gives a lecture on predation in the human species.
Read now at Duke University Press
All Too Human: A Conversation with Elizabeth Grosz
Elizabeth Grosz; Simone Stirner
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
Simone Stirner: In a lecture in 2007, you expressed the wish for a five-year moratorium
on speaking about the self, about the subject, its experience, its
affects, rejecting the emphasis on the personal.1 The five years have passed, but I still apologize in advance for
beginning my questions with a very subjective, even affective response
to your writing. When I first read Chaos, Territory, Art, and, shortly after, Becoming Undone, I found the thinking you suggest quite challenging, at times unsettling, but also, in a strange way, comforting.2 Challenging, in its methodological turn to Darwin’s conception of life
and the interventions it makes to decenter the human, rethinking the
human in a gesture of moving beyond this category, toward other forms of
life.
Read now at Duke University Press
Planetary Antigones: The Environmental Situation and the Wandering Condition
Frédéric Neyrat
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
Many contemporary thinkers strive to
imagine what a world without human beings might be like. These thinkers include
philosophers like Quentin Meillassoux conceptualizing an “ancestral” Earth pre-dating
human life or Eugene Thacker testing how philosophy may––or may not––respond to
horror of a “world-without-us”; they are journalists like Alan Weisman,
author of The World without Us, a book that imagines what would happen to
buildings and infrastructures if human beings mysteriously vanished; or
paleobiologists like Jan Zalasiewicz, well known for his work on the
Anthropocene, who in The Earth after Us: What Legacy Will Humans Leave in the
Rocks? wonders whether, in a very distant future, an extraterrestrial
intelligence could detect on Earth geological traces of a now gone human
presence.
Why such an enthusiasm for reflections concerning the disappearance of humanity?
Read now at Duke University Press
The Descola Variations: The Ontological Geography of Beyond Nature and Culture
Peter Skafish
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
Much about Philippe Descola is exactly what you end up deciding you
might have expected from someone holding a chair at the Collège de
France. So measured is his tone when discussing what is clearly an
extremely wide learning that it becomes obvious that this is someone
with the tact and discretion of a politician, and thus the capacity to
survive the complex trajectory leading to a professor-ship at that
almost inaccessibly elite institution. Nothing in his appearance
disconfirms it: his considerable height, still full white hair and
beard, and long, masculine face give him a patrician air that you, the
disoriented foreigner, imagine to be like that of many of his Republican
forebears interred up the hill in the Panthéon. Objective criteria
agree—France’s Centre national de la recherche scientifique conferred
upon him its highest honor, a medallion d’or usually reserved
for genius in the natural sciences, he presided until recently over the
anthropological laboratory founded by Claude Lévi-Strauss, and a major,
celebrated exhibition at Musée de quai Branley was a result of his
work—while a first meeting at his office might as well be with a
mid-level political official, the staff assuring you that the Monsieur,
while running late, will still see you, and he himself later welcoming
you to his office with entreaties to “Sit down, please sit down, make
yourself comfortable!” that are accompanied by a stream
of unprompted laughter so loud and prolonged that it unnerves you until
you realize that it was intended to be reassuring. (This is famous
laughter.)
Read now at Duke University Press
Losing Manhood: Animality and Plasticity in the (Neo)Slave Narrative
Zakiyyah Iman Jackson
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
Slavery and colonialism not only catalyzed the conscription of black
people into hegemonically imperialist and racialized conceptions of
“modernity” and “universal humanity” but also inaugurated Western
modernity’s condition of possibility, initiating a chain of events that
have given rise to a transnational capitalist order. In light of this
history, it stands to reason that we should critically remember New
World slavery as epochal rupture.1 Slavery’s archival footprint is a ledger system that placed black
humans, horses, cattle, and household items all on the same bill of
purchase. This ledger’s biopolitical arithmetic—its calculation of
humanity—dislocated, depersonalized, and collapsed difference, except in the area of market value. The ledger’s life promised the social death of those enslaved.
“Slave humanity” is an aporia with which we have yet to reckon and
which, perhaps, marks the limit of the reckonable. Rather than view the
paradoxical predicament of enslaved humanity through the lens of lack or
absence, I contend that humanity itself is fractured and relational
instead of a single trajectory or a unitary sign. In place of assuming
the virtuousness of human recognition or humanization, I interrogate the
methods upon which an imperialist and racialized conception of
“universal humanity” attempted to “humanize” blackness.
Read now at Duke University Press
“Shadow Boxing”: Empty Blows, Practice Steps, and Nature’s Hold
Anne-Lise François
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
In the Oxford English Dictionary, the word shadow-box appears as a verb both transitive and intransitive: “to box (against) an imaginary opponent, as a form of training.” In his 1991 book translated as Ecological Enlightenment,
the German sociologist and philosopher of risk Ulrich Beck uses the
metaphor in the course of distinguishing “the new ecological conflict,”
in which nothing is at stake except “negatives: losses, devastation,
threats,” from “the old industrial conflict of labor against capital”
that was (once upon a time) conceivable as a struggle for “positives:
profits, prosperity, consumer goods.” Written in the aftermath of Chernobyl, Beck’s words bear repeating in light of recent catastrophes such as the BP–Deepwater
Horizon oil hemorrhage in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 or the Fukushima
Daiichi nuclear melt-downs in 2011, widely publicized accidents whose
unfinished harm overlaps with, and cannot be separated from, the ongoing
violence of systemic forms of energy-intensive resource extraction,
including tar sands exploitation and gas-and oil-hydrofracking...
Read now at Duke University Press
Articles
World-Making and Grammatical Impasse
Daniel Colucciello Barber
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:
To speak of the secular is to speak of the world. Or, more precisely,
it is to speak of the age of the world, which for Christianity marked a
time between the Christ’s advent and return, and which for the secular
modern came to mark a time in which “religion” would be superseded.
However one goes about parsing the continuities and/or discontinuities
of Christianity and the secular, one ends up with
the fact—the evident doing and making—of the world. This is to say that
the world demonstrates an immense staying power, namely, the power to
decide what stays (and what does not).
The world survives. It certainly survives its Christian formation, but if it does so
through an apparent identification with the secular, it may nonetheless
survive the critique of the secular. More essential than the question of
whether the post-secular (as that which follows from the critique of
the secular) diverges from the secular is the question of whether the
post-secular (or the critique of the secular) diverges from the world.
The survival of the world, after all, is a matter of reproduction, of a
development and futurity that—even (or especially) when emergent in the
guise of crisis or threat—manages to extend itself in ever more supple
and micro-calibrated degrees.
Read now at Duke University Press
Review Essays
Liberal Modernity and Its Fictions: Lisa Lowe’s The Intimacies of Four Continents
Hossein Ayazi
A review of Lowe, Lisa, The Intimacies of Four Continents (Durham: Duke University Press, 2015).
Read now at Duke University Press
The Ghostly Gate of Michel de Certeau
Kathryn Crim
A review of de Certeau, Michel, The Mystic Fable, Volume Two, edited by Luce Giard, translated by Michael B. Smith (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2015).
Read now at Duke University Press
The Lyric and Its Discontents
Isobel Palmer
A review of Culler, Jonathan, Theory of the Lyric (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2015).
Read now at Duke University Press
Divisions of Labor: Between Cheah’s Worlds
Ragini Tharoor Srinivasan
A review of Cheah, Pheng, What Is a World? On Postcolonial Literature as World Literature (Durham: Duke University Press, 2016).
Read now at Duke University Press
New Humanisms
Chad Shomura
A review of Lee, Rachel C., The Exquisite Corpse of Asian America: Biopolitics, Biosociality, and Posthuman Ecologies (New York: New York University Press, 2014), and Weheliye, Alexander G., Habeas Viscus: Racializing Assemblages, Biopolitics, and Black Feminist Theories of the Human (Durham: Duke University Press, 2014).
Read now at Duke University Press
Volume 25.1-2 is available at Duke University Press, Project Muse, and JSTOR. Qui Parle is edited by an independent group of graduate students at the University of California, Berkeley and published by Duke University Press.